OEM MagSafe Chargers vs Cheap Imposters: Teardown for Truth
Anywhere premium products are produced, there are unsavory folks trying to make a quick buck selling cheap knockoffs. It happens in every industry, from clothes to food to tech. But in recent years, counterfeit electronics have surpassed nearly all other categories of counterfeit goods by dollar value, and Apple, being the de facto high-end electronics manufacturer, makes for a prime target.
But you’d never be caught buying counterfeit electronics, because you can tell the difference, can’t you?
A Brief History of Apple Counterfeits
One of the most common Apple products, where knockoffs are passed as OEM, are MagSafe adapters. There was even a huge controversy a few years ago where Amazon was selling knockoffs as OEM; Amazon has since fixed that particular issue, but knockoffs are still out there, and detecting them is getting harder.
How To Spot A Fake?
If you’re looking to buy a replacement charger and want to know if the one you are getting is real, it may be hard to tell. It used to be that knockoffs were easy to spot. Recently, these counterfeiters have started doing a pretty good job replicating Apple’s exterior design to look quite a bit like the OEM parts they are trying to replace. Of course, the easiest thing to do is make sure you buy your charger from a trusted source.
At Beetstech, we make sure everything we send out is thoroughly tested before it reaches the customer. Obviously, anything that advertises itself as third party should be taken as such. There are a few cosmetic differences on the less than honest brands, often the lettering will be a slightly different shade, darker, or even a little blurry. These differences can be hard to spot without a side by side comparison.
Notice the knockoff (bottom) has darker text.
But let’s say you already bought one, or maybe you bought a MacBook secondhand and suspect it came with a less than reputable MagSafe. Luckily, there a few easy ways to tell a fake from the real thing, once you have them in your hands.
The quickest way is to plug it into your MacBook. If the LED turns on right away, or in less than one second, it’s definitely a fake. OEM MagSafe LEDs are turned on by the actual computer. There is a brief handshake protocol where the Mac looks to make sure everything is working correctly with the MagSafe. When it is satisfied everything is in order, it sends a signal to MagSafe internal chip to turn the LED on. This process takes a little over one second, causing a noticeable delay in the LED. The LED on fakes may also stay on after they unplugged. I have seen some that have stayed on for close to five seconds, a sure sign they were fakes.
OEM
The knockoff comes on
Several sources online told me that you can also check the authenticity in the system information. Go to About this Mac>System Report>Hardware>Power, then scroll to the bottom.
OEM MagSafe
Counterfeit MagSafe
This has all the information about the MagSafe, including the serial number. Some knockoffs might not have this information, but sometimes good fakes do have some of the correct looking information that looks reliable to the untrained eye. It is possible that the serial number doesn’t match anything, but since Apple has no way to search these serial numbers, I can not always recommend this as a reliable way to determine the authenticity of the MagSafe. One thing I have noticed is that a good knockoff may be labeled as a certain wattage, but the System recognized it as a different wattage. So, that’s something to watch for. This information is stored in a microchip in the MagSafe connector, so it may be the knockoff simply used the wrong one.
There are a few other indicators that a MagSafe is not real. One quick test is the weight. Often knockoffs will be lighter since they use cheaper smaller components. Again, the easiest way to know is holding a known OEM MagSafe in one hand and the suspect one in the other hand and comparing. When I weighed the two 85W chargers I was comparing, the OEM weighed in at 306 grams and the knockoff was 200 grams. Not a huge difference, but it is noticeable.
There are a few other indicators that a MagSafe is not real. One quick test is the weight. Often knockoffs will be lighter since they use cheaper smaller components. Again, the easiest way to know is holding a known OEM MagSafe in one hand and the suspect one in the other hand and comparing. When I weighed the two 85W chargers I was comparing, the OEM weighed in at 306 grams and the knockoff was 200 grams. Not a huge difference, but it is noticeable.
There also may be noticeable differences in the seams. Apple has fairly strict manufacturing standards, while the cheap ones usually don’t. This often leads to the seams being less-than-perfect. The collapsible cord holder tabs can also be looser, or sometimes they can be harder to extend. Apple’s will be secure yet operate smoothly
The fake MagSafe has uneven seams. Apple's cord-holding tabs fit snugly.
Teardown
Let’s get into the insides, the place where the differences become stark. This is where the answer to, “Does it really matter?” becomes most obvious.
The first thing I noticed when taking these apart is how much easier the knockoff MagSafe came apart. I barely had to apply any pressure in order to crack the glue. Once it was cracked the entire thing came apart easily. With the OEM charger, it was much more of a fight. A lot more pressure was required to even crack the glue, and even then I had go along the seam and keep pulling glue apart. That shouldn’t really be a big deal considering there is no reason to take them apart, other than to see what’s inside.
OEM MagSafe
Knockoff Charger
Now that we are inside, the differences are clear from the start. Apple’s MagSafe is extremely well protected. The whole thing is encased in a copper sleeve with a protective tape underneath it. This is most likely to protect the device from any outside interference and to keep it from causing any interference, a small Faraday cage. The knockoff has a small piece of cheap steel. This doesn’t seem to provide much of anything other than a little bit of extra weight. We can also see that, sure enough, the ground post is not hooked to anything. Even if was made of metal (it’s not, it’s chromed plastic) it would not provide any connection to a ground from a wall outlet. It is literally cosmetic. Another small difference of note is the screws. Apple has taken the time to countersink their screws, where the knockoff’s don’t. This probably has more to do with saving space than anything else, but it does show an extra layer of care by Apple.
When we remove those “protective” layers, it’s like we’re not even looking at the same item.
OEM MagSafe
Knockoff Charger
Apple’s MagSafe is crammed full of components. There are two transformers. The main one is a bit larger, making it a bit more reliable. These two transformers provide higher and lower voltage. The knockoff only has one, which is why it has a constant output of 20 volts. It’s hard to tell, but to the right of the larger transformer (the big yellow tape covered one) is another covered piece: an internal processing chip that communicates with the laptop to decide which power setting to use.
Then, there are the safety issues. The knockoff charger uses smaller and cheaper resistors, transistors, and capacitors. The main capacitor in the knockoff is larger, but the rating is actually higher on the Apple OEM MagSafe. Cutting these corners means there are more places where things can go wrong. I’ve witnessed what happens when a resistor pops, and it’s not fun to see smoke and a funny smell coming from your electronics.
There are also whole components missing; some of them just provide more channels to keep the electricity in check, but a big one that is missing is the Power Factor Controller This device makes sure you are pulling the right type of power from your AC wall socket. It is required in Europe, and not having it can lead to higher costs from energy companies and a less-than-efficient conversion from AC to DC (the whole point of a MagSafe).
When we flip these over, we can see even more problems.
OEM MagSafe
Fake Charger
With more components, we would expect to see more circuitry on the back, but wow! What a difference. Again, we see Apple using resistors with much higher ratings. Also, despite having vastly more components, Apple has a more organized circuitry. On top of that, they have kept the proper distance for parts that should never touch. You can see a clear line of delineation (starting in the bottom left corner and heading 45 degrees up) that keeps high and low voltage separate. Even with the all the extra space the knockoff has, it’s harder to see any such safety line.
In fact, there a few places where the solder just overlaps onto other components or comes dangerously close. This is visible in the lower left of this image. Two components are accidentally soldered together.
Fake Charger with bad soldering job
Remember, you’re plugging this into a wall socket and then into your computer. These kinds of mistakes can mean more than just a failed charger; they can ruin your computer or, worse, start a fire. Considering the complete lack of any other safety measures in the knockoff charger, I wouldn’t want to take that gamble.
Takeaway
Ultimately, I would say it’s best to always buy from a trusted source. Even then, check your MagSafe to make sure it is a legitimate. If you end up with a fake, don’t use it. If you bought from a reputable retailer, you should be able to get a refund or exchange. It might cost a little more to know you’re getting an OEM MagSafe, but it is definitely worth it. The lack of any quality control or safety measures are worrisome, and the simple fact that it doesn’t behave correctly means a risk to your battery and your power bill. They might be cheaper initially, but they will cost you more down the road.
Like this post
17 comments
Leave a comment
Recommended posts
High Sierra and Testing RAM
With macOS 10.13, otherwise known as High Sierra, Apple introduced an ambitious EFI update. Several of the changes include: the introduction of the Apple File System, support for NVMe drives, and the usual batch of security updates. However, these EFI updates can cause some unwanted behavior when you test your Apple computer’s memory. At Beetstech, we use a long-time industry standard, MemTest86 to perform a comprehensive test of each computer’s RAM.
But never the type to blindly accept test results, strange testing outcomes led us to discover a bug in MemTest86 affecting computers running the new EFI firmware. In short, the newly updated EFI causes MemTest86 to incorrectly fail certain tests. But there is good news: while normal operation of MemTest86 is limited under these new EFI updates, we also discovered some simple workarounds for testing your Apple’s memory in MemTest86.
So let’s dive into how we discovered the MemTest bug, devised a reliable work-around, and get into some nitty gritty details of MemTest86 operation.
MacBook Air Power-On Pads – Location & Use
They go by “jumper pads”, “short-circuit pads”, “power pads”, and “power-on pads”. Whatever you call them, there are two bits of metal on your MacBook logic board that can force your laptop to boot up, even if the power button won’t do the trick.
The Ultimate Guide to Apple’s Proprietary SSDs
Remember the good ol’ days of carrying a spare battery, upgrading your own RAM, maybe even adding a second hard drive? If you’re an Apple user, those luxuries may be behind us, but upgrading your own solid state drive is still a privilege the Apple overlords allow us to have, for now that is.
Despite retaining the ability to upgrade your own SSD, ever since Apple introduced their proprietary “blade” SSDs in 2010, the task hasn’t been as simple as it once was. Apple talks up read and write speeds, but they rarely dive into the nitty gritty details of the technology behind the SSDs they use — drives specially designed only for Apple computers.
After countless questions, both from customers and our own staff, we decided to start our own investigation into the hardware involved. You have to be a bit of a private eye to uncover the secrets behind these drives, and the deeper we looked, the more surprises we found.
Your Hard Drive Cable Is A Ticking Time Bomb
Owners of a Unibody MacBook Pro laptop are probably already aware that failure of the hard drive flex cable is a common issue. While it affects just about the entire Unibody lineup, the Mid 2012 MacBook Pro 13″ (Model A1278) is especially prone to this type of failure.
What is it that makes the Mid 2012 release special in this regard? A design flaw in the flex cable that seems to be compounded by the properties of the aluminum housing.
Our repair services department noticed this issue when they’d replace a bad cable, only to have the customer return a few months later with another bad cable. And possibly again with yet another bad cable. It didn’t matter if we used a used cable or a new cable in the replacement. Customers kept returning with the same persistent issue. We had to figure out what was causing the issue and find a solution.
Thanks for posting this! I just mistakenly bought one of these, and was concerned. It looks quite authentic, but the power prong doesn’t easily extend and the tabs for wrapping the cable don’t open at all; clearly not a “factory refurbished” adaptor. I was going to weight the authentic one and the likely knock-off to confirm, but you’ve gone many steps further.
Excellent write-up, really appreciated the thoroughness. I always warn people not to buy these. Apple’s $80 price tag for a new magsafe adapter is hard to stomach, but it’s nowhere near as bad as dealing with a zapped computer, or a house-fire. They’re definitley not UL-listed, or safe. They also spray EFI and transistor hash noise like crazy. Bring an AM radio near one in operation, and you’ll see what I mean.
It’s amazing that these counterfeits make it into the country, and are so prolific.
Thanks Jason. Keep up the good fight. No one should use these terrible fakes.
Nomeclatura dos 2 diodos Schottky do carregador ou esquema eletrônico..
This hit piece is nothing but unsubstantiated fearmongering and predation on consumers who don’t know any better.
You are incorrect. While there are some errors in the writeup, for example calling out a close solder joint when both are connected to the same node, the knock-off they looked at in this article is inferior. In fact, it appears dangerous. The required isolation barrier, in this case comprising specific creepage, clearance, and/or reinforced insulation rules is at best poorly implemented in the knockoff. The heatsink itself doesn’t have any insulation and being a common node that spans line-side and isolated-side conductors probably violates safety clearance rules. I wouldn’t be surprised if a teardown of the transformer also showed a failure to meet reinforced or double insulated safety standards. Further, a full power load test and temperature measurement of the knock-off adapter’s surface would probably show that the steady state skin temperature exceeds the safety requirements in at least a few places. Calling out the number of components isn’t necessarily valid, as frequently more advanced and/or highly integrated designs have fewer components, even as functionality rises (and that tends to make them more reliable). The same can be said about the size of the passives, when properly engineered. That said, it’s evident that the design, layout, and assembly are superior in the Apple version, in this case (starting with things as basic as the quality of the solder mask and the use of FR4/5 vs the phenolic in the knockoff). They also have a more evolved reflow process and there are no hacks (like the “oops” shunt included in the knockoff). It’s pretty likely that the Apple adapter delivers higher steady-state power, better regulation, and in certain scenarios lower temperatures internal to the laptop (which is why there is a dual-voltage output and P.S. Beetstech…dual voltage doesn’t require two transformers, especially in an SMPS). The Apple product, in this case is no doubt superior, and the most important way that manifests is strict employment of safety isolation barriers. While $80 is a steep markup (they are probably paying about $15 for that device … the knockoff is probaby $5 out the factory door), if it’s between that and electrocution, it’s worth being careful. (There’s a tragic story of a young girl that got electrocuted in her bed by a knock-off iphone adapter. Having analyzed some of those, I have no doubt it’s authentic). That said there are safe aftermarket brands…just not the $5-$15 ones that litter Amazon and the internet in general. Don’t underestimate the importance of a good isolation barrier that is both electrically and mechanically robust…doing so will get you killed, if not your laptop.
Oh yeah, one more thing. For a safety-rated device such as an adapter to meet IEC and/or UL standards one of the requirements is for the internal safety-critical components to also meet those standards. In particular, the transformer must be validated and then labeled with a marking identifying it as being built to specification. The latter is visible in the Apple adapter, “LITEON SL-130…..” The knock-off has no such label on its transformer (at least as visible in the pictures). Without such a label, it’s a standards violation to have an external safety marking such as CE or UL, because it doesn’t meet the standards. That means the analyed adapter almost certainly didn’t get an independent safety evaluation (which isn’t surprising because it does not look like it would pass), and if it has a mark on the case, it’s fake. Fake safety and EMI markings on knock-off adapters are a common problem. In fact, they can’t be legally sold in brick-and-mortar retail stores in the US, but Amazon and other online retailers exploit a loophole in the law because they are not brick and mortar. P.S. The same thing is true of the PCB…the Apple PCB has a 94V-0 fire rating mark…note the complete absence of a comparable marking on the knockoff.
Thanks for the info
Not all 3rd party adapters are bad. I’ve used several 3rd party adapters that don’t have most of the issues listed. I agree that the safest option is to get a genuine adapter. There is obviously great variance in quality in the 3rd party market and I bet there are hundreds of different chargers.
Excelente Articulo gracias
Woww amazing description. Thank for the tips and help. I’m based in Indonesia where it is pretty hard to find an original MagSafe. I was considering to buy a fake one, it is the only one I can find here. I will have to look for more options then. Thanks again !
There is a big problem with audio noise when you use a fake mac power for audio interface and condensor mics. the amount of floor noise that originates from a fake is not acceptable for audio recording.
I bought a used laptop, the charger gets extremely hot if I leave plugged in to power source. Does this mean it’s a fake, and is it dangerous? I am a 93 yr.old Female needing advice
OK
This is very helpful. We ordered some because the description showed as Apple OEM and we certainly do not want to resell them to our customers as anything other than Genuine. Thank you.
How can i get schematics 85W mag safe power adepter 2 i want 3 componets details only its fired i dont no its details I think its 3 components are C052 and R051, F300, its located near to out put line Schematic other wise its 3 components details can you plz …..
Thanks for this. I’ve had a lot of trouble with fake chargers. They tend to die quite quickly which means they don’t represent any sort of saving as they have to be replaced.